{"type":"session","version":3,"id":"097c82a7-cdda-432b-9df6-00ca388f2e21","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:43.531Z","cwd":"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace"}
{"type":"model_change","id":"7e65ccd8","parentId":null,"timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:43.531Z","provider":"sub2api","modelId":"gpt-5.3-codex"}
{"type":"thinking_level_change","id":"49d0f21f","parentId":"7e65ccd8","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:43.531Z","thinkingLevel":"low"}
{"type":"custom","customType":"model-snapshot","data":{"timestamp":1772942503532,"provider":"sub2api","modelApi":"openai-responses","modelId":"gpt-5.3-codex"},"id":"9e19c72e","parentId":"49d0f21f","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:43.532Z"}
{"type":"message","id":"9581d476","parentId":"9e19c72e","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:43.538Z","message":{"role":"user","content":[{"type":"text","text":"[Sun 2026-03-08 12:01 GMT+8] [Subagent Context] You are running as a subagent (depth 1/1). Results auto-announce to your requester; do not busy-poll for status.\n\n[Subagent Task]: 你是门下省（The Auditor）。审查当前宪章 `org/CONSTITUTION_v1.md` 与即将执行的多subagent调度实践，生成《执行前审计清单》：安全红线、成本红线、升级条件、否决条件。要求输出保存到 `org/AUDIT_CHECKLIST.md`，并在回复中给出“通过/驳回 + 理由”。"}],"timestamp":1772942503536}}
{"type":"message","id":"c0680271","parentId":"9581d476","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:47.349Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"**Reviewing project files**","thinkingSignature":"{\"id\":\"rs_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4a97f7c81918ef96316afc37b98\",\"type\":\"reasoning\",\"encrypted_content\":\"gAAAAABprPSqZlels6GVXd5flyxLSkmBzuFBGOHGWwgNyfVsYQn1kAEmLpRU0qApNTQbehNN2WftYA4kBABrGWUHmNm3M656VHTh84i6IbrW3o8qwko9CXjzAV00xOy0plblpZSEsQZcWxt2NmC55QCjJluRMrVnc2sF8FjM0Ov00dIEskvg8ULqr1R7Ib7Ifuje0JRTMC3vLAq6EjMGZdeT-vDiEr8rG1wMjRgJUfrXtDU9wJ0SjejfU8Zi1fP2FX6VY6l8puIEZf_BaHj5tP5mZH3GDVRlaRdtSQK56Ytiii09H7WXnN3symye6HMAXeoEe9YsBq6V8ok7mjhLrb39UoXnwEa5m5J8ptCjs9OeUH93eayCfdi2JcjO0HEbUfyjkkIO3Q8RGJ7h9agQVwpBJRqoLL5tQ9LNphwQ3mFlKPKxLAxlwRkTDtp6NDY_EzdmPcsBewFxi5KuGfJN7iBVcPjWRLnRBIuzDubJHaP4RIGYAuaI0uCZvFviUfsAeoFmdChzHvqDiRSh2HIMNBhH4rplC3H40LXjF6P16fzVUq0BlaDofeKbsD4yNDNYDLPTgz54NClx2AJRC7c1HsPdGboycfvTVHBQJcjJmWnY56ktDWBSCgg8tgMP3AmUVRyrujKAXFcHoCaTCMyBA4dooT81BS-mE-3vKUzkqONygrQkKmKojTyl8CtboullM8gUeXWwbWhkMoGfeO3qcj6lQJjFyaajie8vatq7TPxCfj_DOGcq2SYWgrifqL6g51X7afDZTmtL72k7ckFIx2LcUYKLY1KNkhLxfyEkLxhnXyEWNgIv1uKEEtAORO5T1aJ4sNJUykLDQRB_Zz6Bi3JoKbqfb0ZgVvLbl1QJesouhV81Xe22oMCZzkYUUieFze6OFbdiNtAAY4FgS8izUu3IDgS0tKlVu8mecV5JPH9_H49cYIboXBuISa7BV8N3_TYBSgYNspeV2LZXpzn-inH4Ipb-FBIayahDpDXlfYMm6-1yk0DvqxbF1GViAxy5qPUQrxGkyGq6eSyk8W8dtiMiUFcK_8gpmLqnNC4exN2cgyDmXjqEHbeqaJ-UNkCxRUdtfqKyNQ-rnXM9aHfcd9p990eEKftOiFxiUF32OQoU_i_LJnxcxZx12UjKZCpsbN3zMz3OnRI7LZ5z1vv85wTTfyCnjbuxAaVqEZCbd11OUT9mq7xg6XjHr_oOGc0_uefElJlXbHanJu4tayBN8VTpG3siu2h3Qw==\",\"summary\":[{\"type\":\"summary_text\",\"text\":\"**Reviewing project files**\"}]}"},{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_0d9LdrPx4Zi6eM2eH5wDxlzT|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4aafaa08191b36159a02c5a4e50","name":"exec","arguments":{"command":"ls -R","workdir":"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace"},"partialJson":"{\"command\":\"ls -R\",\"workdir\":\"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace\"}"}],"api":"openai-responses","provider":"sub2api","model":"gpt-5.3-codex","usage":{"input":9142,"output":92,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":9234,"cost":{"input":0,"output":0,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1772942503538}}
{"type":"message","id":"fc1b8f20","parentId":"c0680271","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:47.370Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_0d9LdrPx4Zi6eM2eH5wDxlzT|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4aafaa08191b36159a02c5a4e50","toolName":"exec","content":[{"type":"text","text":"AGENTS.md\nBOOTSTRAP.md\nHEARTBEAT.md\nIDENTITY.md\nMEMORY.md\nSOUL.md\nTOOLS.md\nUSER.md\nmemory\norg\n\n./memory:\n2026-03-07-approval-config.md\n2026-03-07-cannot-convert-argument-to-a-b.md\n2026-03-07-capabilities-none.md\n2026-03-07-openclaw-status.md\n2026-03-07-soul-update.md\n2026-03-08.md\n\n./org:\nCONSTITUTION_v1.md\nROLE_CARDS.md\nVAL_RUNBOOK.md"}],"details":{"status":"completed","exitCode":0,"durationMs":15,"aggregated":"AGENTS.md\nBOOTSTRAP.md\nHEARTBEAT.md\nIDENTITY.md\nMEMORY.md\nSOUL.md\nTOOLS.md\nUSER.md\nmemory\norg\n\n./memory:\n2026-03-07-approval-config.md\n2026-03-07-cannot-convert-argument-to-a-b.md\n2026-03-07-capabilities-none.md\n2026-03-07-openclaw-status.md\n2026-03-07-soul-update.md\n2026-03-08.md\n\n./org:\nCONSTITUTION_v1.md\nROLE_CARDS.md\nVAL_RUNBOOK.md","cwd":"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace"},"isError":false,"timestamp":1772942507368}}
{"type":"message","id":"66aabd10","parentId":"fc1b8f20","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:51.725Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"**Preparing to review scheduling docs**","thinkingSignature":"{\"id\":\"rs_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4acb26481918921667081fc2a40\",\"type\":\"reasoning\",\"encrypted_content\":\"gAAAAABprPSvJhLafPyRKWaRVryyeyVHgxWDZ3ld_TcWS1mjV9XYyh08FAybRDmh5bPsbyCPBZODq-e62TZpBQAENzDVOQ0ftJ7JnXQLU-OfGyszaAzb5MKv6uhgVpqTAWgjMe4inYRDSVwZGPuf6nM-hiNYoYsJ50nlunQMZwCmnk8q_g6HSoxA4qEWW1Af2_35qv959CtOEiUfywjm2SOVSvsqhCvzybVtS5ESj_5jzqR4_fIPHKZcrj83-WIWf6qpOvrxYuDfnWMiFi_ON9jTlXgaxzFXIy_xWUbgmP7Kr3H3zcs3QBmX9VhJ77I3gI4lKOc2E6lK5bvQ6o5iEQfImeT5jNcVkd1FDML-h0owrCTOiGAwT5-bwYW82anmmDHogQYna0MQEb38y7hRaqdq-PPFuly2vgXhL6fvhkHhZy_MlxAeIdLdMUJkDlsk2XxOb1n4L8a4bCfCLGjMi6pb5ni8SPm6r4wpmA4NPfdnqOIEgB2qCbMQTH31T1rE4FkttSkOTtNbXJuWt1ldf4EXQ38Ux6UjA13fmtZCgaMQeitd6pT_rpghpim3F4yIgbMb8IPzWtcv-YEp2T_NhcBCiDDqIMj5Brqz1Wc7Zsfr-EXQZ9i66CLldMGz58fWWg3SCfNxejHdXaLbBmy37FNkRKzYAyvgls2zadKNVF1yAYB_fFnKEdDo46ZftRlKAim3z7m3jMKWDaSncgzRHLwfcIO0kosTkSNj12kB6X-mrjSYpccMTfQJIVlq9XIaw0s8NzLg84BdF_8JHv3cUDY-Pem0C-I8pKPvzbOa2HtPDlMBN2sW4ddGIxT7fucbL--nDGeaKpCqtf2OwVHngPQw42yyIHQszGYX28fgtSMLSX-inFC7CIpEMlbH-7kKoEyGmDuzzlqH5x3mmLSxNKGKsxpP-XrZNoaBbppiQD0FubwlfufMkHWzXjc0E2Kxsije9QhX_xw0qXWbAVAVHr2JO6LbvQg79HNEMwD7S42_YLS36c5L48GlSMkjzcieOPgWwCCVezu6j0GVeDVS04e-cIv4yuwftUS4JfukFrRZq96b1ymJkTCKpogqFVSpF2WVrAwxilGpZ7vy14ZDmV4e9rgBGMLu_Q==\",\"summary\":[{\"type\":\"summary_text\",\"text\":\"**Preparing to review scheduling docs**\"}]}"},{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_lbOzkmQqE5FqGXOUHLRHc7us|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4af744c8191800ab35958fce492","name":"read","arguments":{"path":"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace/org/CONSTITUTION_v1.md"},"partialJson":"{\"path\":\"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace/org/CONSTITUTION_v1.md\"}"},{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_Oe9rFRkPZSAoPFYhrv0tYHtD|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4af745c8191bbe7ffae002f0091","name":"read","arguments":{"path":"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace/org/VAL_RUNBOOK.md"},"partialJson":"{\"path\":\"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace/org/VAL_RUNBOOK.md\"}"},{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_FV8tVvDuZRXgmMHf5BbZaGLR|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4af74748191b756d06c965e5d5d","name":"read","arguments":{"path":"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace/org/ROLE_CARDS.md"},"partialJson":"{\"path\":\"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace/org/ROLE_CARDS.md\"}"}],"api":"openai-responses","provider":"sub2api","model":"gpt-5.3-codex","usage":{"input":285,"output":152,"cacheRead":9088,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":9525,"cost":{"input":0,"output":0,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1772942507371}}
{"type":"message","id":"4c46e3e8","parentId":"66aabd10","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:51.735Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_lbOzkmQqE5FqGXOUHLRHc7us|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4af744c8191800ab35958fce492","toolName":"read","content":[{"type":"text","text":"# 三省六部多智能体协作宪章 v1\n\n## 0. 最高原则\n\n1. 用户目标优先（谷老板战略意图 > 一切局部优化）\n2. 安全与可控优先于速度\n3. 成本可见、过程可追踪、结果可复盘\n4. 明显不应认可动作：Val可直接否决\n5. 重大/不明确决策：必须上报谷老板最终拍板（谷老板保留最终否决权）\n\n---\n\n## 1. 组织结构\n\n### 决策大脑（三省）\n- 中书省（The Architect）：需求结构化、任务草拟\n- 门下省（The Auditor）：安全/逻辑/成本审计\n- 尚书省（The Controller）：调度分发、状态跟踪、结果汇总\n\n### 专项执行（六部）\n- 吏部（Personnel Agent）：模型与技能配置、Agent编组\n- 户部（Resources Agent）：Token/成本/资源监控\n- 礼部（Rites Agent）：输出风格与交互规范\n- 兵部（Guardian Agent）：系统安全与执行前安全确认\n- 刑部（Justice Agent）：失败分析、调试与修复路径\n- 工部（Worker Agent）：工程执行（代码/数据/自动化）\n\n---\n\n## 2. 强制流转（State Machine）\n\n1. Intake（需求进入）\n2. Draft（中书草拟）\n3. Audit（门下审计）\n4. Approve/Reject（通过或驳回）\n5. Dispatch（尚书分发六部）\n6. Execute（执行）\n7. Verify（校验）\n8. Report（汇总上报）\n9. Archive（归档复盘）\n\n### 双签铁律\n- 工部执行前：必须完成「门下 + 兵部」双签\n- 任何失败：先进入刑部，再决定重试/回滚/升级\n\n---\n\n## 3. 权限边界\n\n## Val（大总管）\n- 有权：\n  - 否决明显不合理动作\n  - 调度与重排执行顺序\n  - 发起风险预警与预算闸门\n- 无权：\n  - 越权执行重大不明确决策\n  - 代替谷老板做最终战略拍板\n\n## 谷老板\n- 最终决策权 + 最终否决权\n- 重大变更、生效策略、风险承受阈值最终定义者\n\n---\n\n## 4. 升级条件（必须上报）\n\n满足任一条件即上报谷老板：\n- 涉及对外发送或公开发布\n- 涉及不可逆操作（删除/覆盖/资金动作）\n- 涉及隐私外发或安全边界变化\n- 单任务预算/Token预估超阈值\n- 审计结论存在高不确定性\n\n---\n\n## 5. 产出标准（统一模板）\n\n每个Agent交付必须包含：\n- 结论（1-3行）\n- 证据与日志（关键依据）\n- 风险与假设\n- 下一步建议（2-3选项 + 推荐）\n\n---\n\n## 6. 版本与变更\n\n- 版本：v1\n- 生效：2026-03-08\n- 变更规则：任何权限边界调整需谷老板确认\n"}],"isError":false,"timestamp":1772942511733}}
{"type":"message","id":"6cdb8801","parentId":"4c46e3e8","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:51.750Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_Oe9rFRkPZSAoPFYhrv0tYHtD|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4af745c8191bbe7ffae002f0091","toolName":"read","content":[{"type":"text","text":"# Val 调度手册（Runbook）\n\n## A. 接单即执行的流程\n\n1) 复述目标（1句话）\n2) 中书草拟：形成任务单\n3) 门下审计：安全/逻辑/成本\n4) 触发上报判断：\n   - 重大或不明确 -> 立即上报谷老板\n   - 明显不应认可 -> 直接否决并说明原因\n5) 尚书分发六部并设定里程碑\n6) 收敛结果：结论 + 证据 + 风险 + 2~3选项（含推荐）\n\n## B. 任务单模板\n\n- 目标：\n- 范围：\n- 步骤：\n- 所需工具/技能：\n- 风险点：\n- 验收标准：\n- 预算估算（Token/时间）：\n\n## C. 审计模板（门下）\n\n- 安全：通过 / 驳回（理由）\n- 逻辑：通过 / 驳回（理由）\n- 成本：通过 / 需降本（建议）\n- 结论：放行 / 补充后放行 / 驳回\n\n## D. 失败处理模板（刑部）\n\n- 失败阶段：\n- 根因定位：\n- 修复方案A/B：\n- 回滚策略：\n- 是否需要上报：是/否\n\n## E. 汇报模板（给谷老板）\n\n- 结论：\n- 当前状态：\n- 风险与取舍：\n- 选项：1/2/3（推荐X）\n- 需要你拍板的点：\n"}],"isError":false,"timestamp":1772942511749}}
{"type":"message","id":"cef3669e","parentId":"6cdb8801","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:01:51.757Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_FV8tVvDuZRXgmMHf5BbZaGLR|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4af74748191b756d06c965e5d5d","toolName":"read","content":[{"type":"text","text":"# 角色卡（Role Cards）\n\n## Val（Concierge / User Proxy / 大总管）\n- 使命：把谷老板意图稳定转化为可执行、多智能体协同结果\n- KPI：目标对齐率、升级准确率、交付稳定性\n- 输入：用户意图、上下文、系统状态\n- 输出：任务编排、风险判断、汇总决策建议\n\n## 中书省（Architect）\n- 输入：自然语言需求\n- 输出：结构化任务单（目标/步骤/工具/验收）\n\n## 门下省（Auditor）\n- 输入：任务单\n- 输出：审计结论（通过/驳回/补充条件）\n\n## 尚书省（Controller）\n- 输入：过审任务\n- 输出：分发计划、执行状态、结果汇总\n\n## 吏部（Personnel）\n- 输出：模型选型与技能编组建议\n\n## 户部（Resources）\n- 输出：预算估算、Token监控、成本警戒\n\n## 礼部（Rites）\n- 输出：表达风格、文档规范、可读性修订\n\n## 兵部（Guardian）\n- 输出：安全检查、执行前红线确认\n\n## 刑部（Justice）\n- 输出：错误定位、修复方案、回归验证策略\n\n## 工部（Worker）\n- 输出：工程成果（代码/数据/脚本/自动化流程）\n"}],"isError":false,"timestamp":1772942511756}}
{"type":"message","id":"3cfd886b","parentId":"cef3669e","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:02:16.188Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"**Creating checklist draft in Chinese**","thinkingSignature":"{\"id\":\"rs_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4b0e7c08191ae74aa5f496e683d\",\"type\":\"reasoning\",\"encrypted_content\":\"gAAAAABprPSzE-aw3xXKXBQPJM06R0dWfA60qiuY9nl0kWa4KgyuxuNgGSf0Sny_YtR8Jl92dpV0jydT4jTQoj32OKbIttuKsYErNrtgHbeNeMAhtleFoLZLsZ3f4LtGpfisYnqxL8K9zrQ6rIIFHoj7g7m4JT2KJzDTo3z1U6XglHBVwIsnTz9u1GhuHz7tw6ZWOWF-wasONepJcfNxxT1K_fk5dbwvZWSy6s1tWeiKLCYvXSS11EZVivrSEL1oxpDmwptTI_3lL4d4bSCU4WQHlrxvCdKRBmB6QZkFaegT1ZEOJHvRidjVp0qArrThCmJJcx02ycF8monR27VlynnQ3rp2TpxcXHof9aIM7fQ1paqM5xmWKIzq4D8NijA2aQIbLJRK-e8GaC_v4Rv7GVrHPsBlUNg6VBgEQpa10X_fitVp9lWoXOVIc6PVUpE0hZnOCHJeKg2f0LeEI-EC6F2UnosCB9UMp20vgqwcdlwiHYqAnJnybKjyQDEIHuFYWddqJljGXzDKJ2AfBLsJGit2GPzCw-KPPRIRiaCaViBodxst0RQmcJgwXDQZ0H_woDby-2yAhUz92XMRPxfZr3uRKkZ69NqhiPsGuqPApTbvnzpJwQVVvsLXHyd3WdAQ4VVO4EqmL-gY4GwoA41OKB-AByTx1dp46lM_ixJCqsI52sm7O3xbWb4McRH-tgoWnmBYZXDxFYyLKGMrSsEJjNTYuuj5QppkT14MdiAQhfr2sN6yU-PD88K2cHg-tTFpiRnkNO25M1vrd6Af9uSrnbmxG_ZSA1DsPUZWh76HbHcj_71XQK-aMmGovvnJCrwMH9Q_lWpqGK1S0QG-cSHIKKKyaz6_ZAgxvcggLqWCmYXej2lESk5DVMiqj03OYLJSG2H408j6YsKcr1plpphNYTEexksHQZUOprf6FEFhj06NCfYwqLbNhL2x0l6fjcSFBh3EFHW6HTRL1Hh6GfFAWxPv_UyxB1aDsqiD68M0h7TP0isl6RQIsMS-aii__wNIgGTjT-3T-NaeaXnRyJPUif6wLHSJ8b98tJaDpqHOJWi8eE8lmtTNlr0isZD6OqIQJmXU5qxx-j9LOV6Y1ZzXT7FOUVidAw9JvfYVtTTG3PAy4VFUkDUyNkRZmDcpollPFTIb1bgcKLdPHrPsFXMdUWxnnBX6uG1ReLsWHoYyoYViinBftzFaRVoNh7c_1oyGIKts2rJUDs514olTGniBsL3-bWh_1bvUp2o7dwKabToZdeR7j2fs9sNcysE3ekUe2oA69hv9ebp51LT-yZ0763OOgtu3KBHAXYuM-EsNMmdoAprSpOoqLTMSwsIemncmyUaU6dmrSobb2eKqGPzbxu7p3TawNz2Gq5tjTVPyTd4Wy6KrcpIpb-lZssDIq51qixCxwuZlf-h6Nw_MqIbZZWGw014Y9TlVR52qeBIfgo9EKl9Z7r2iiK9YY8p6X5P0lbvvJBg88KzyO9WkgwSVI9QSAsd5LecG4w==\",\"summary\":[{\"type\":\"summary_text\",\"text\":\"**Creating checklist draft in Chinese**\"}]}"},{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_C7V4RvF3EDo1E6uConsg9sdo|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4b34c108191a028a4e842327164","name":"write","arguments":{"path":"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace/org/AUDIT_CHECKLIST.md","content":"# 执行前审计清单（门下省）\n\n- 审计对象：`org/CONSTITUTION_v1.md` + 即将执行的多 subagent 调度实践\n- 审计时间：2026-03-08\n- 审计结论：**通过（附硬性前置条件）**\n\n---\n\n## 1) 安全红线（任一命中即停止执行）\n\n1. **未完成双签即进入工部执行**（门下 + 兵部）\n2. **越权决策**：Val 或任何 subagent 代替谷老板拍板重大/不明确事项\n3. **对外发送/公开发布**未先触发上报与授权\n4. **不可逆操作**（删除/覆盖/资金动作）未获明确批准\n5. **隐私外发或安全边界变更**（权限、网络暴露、密钥流转）未经上报\n6. **规避审计链路**：跳过 Audit/Verify/Archive 或缺失可追踪日志\n7. **失败后绕过刑部**直接重试/继续推进\n\n---\n\n## 2) 成本红线（任一命中即触发降级或暂停）\n\n1. **单任务预算未声明**（Token/时间）即开始调度\n2. **实际消耗超过预算上限**且未触发户部预警与降本动作\n3. **并发 subagent 数超出控制阈值**，导致上下文重复/空转调用\n4. **重复审计或重复执行**（同一产出无增量循环）\n5. **高成本工具调用无必要性说明**（浏览器/长链路执行等）\n6. **无里程碑止损点**，出现长时间任务漂移\n\n> 建议默认控制：\n> - 每轮仅保留必要并发（先小并发验证，再扩容）\n> - 每阶段设“预算闸门 + 继续条件”\n\n---\n\n## 3) 升级条件（满足任一必须上报谷老板）\n\n依据宪章第4条并细化如下：\n\n1. 涉及对外发送或公开发布\n2. 涉及不可逆操作\n3. 涉及隐私外发或安全边界变化\n4. 单任务预算/Token 预估超阈值或已超阈值\n5. 审计结论高不确定性（证据不足、前提冲突、结果不可复现）\n6. 跨角色冲突无法在一轮内收敛（如门下与尚书结论冲突）\n7. 连续失败进入刑部后仍无法给出低风险修复路径\n\n---\n\n## 4) 否决条件（门下省可直接驳回）\n\n1. 任务目标不清且验收标准缺失，无法形成可审计任务单\n2. 明确违反“用户目标优先/安全可控优先”最高原则\n3. 缺少关键前置信息但仍要求直接执行\n4. 试图绕开双签铁律或失败处理铁律\n5. 成本明显失衡（收益不匹配风险与资源投入）\n6. 需要谷老板拍板但请求方拒绝上报\n\n---\n\n## 5) 执行前 Gate（放行前必须逐项打勾）\n\n- [ ] 已完成任务单（目标/范围/步骤/工具/风险/验收/预算）\n- [ ] 门下审计结论明确（通过/补充后放行/驳回）\n- [ ] 兵部安全确认完成\n- [ ] 升级条件检查完成（如命中已上报）\n- [ ] 尚书分发含里程碑、责任人、止损点\n- [ ] 失败回路已定义（刑部介入条件 + 回滚策略）\n- [ ] 汇报模板字段齐全（结论/证据/风险/选项+推荐）\n\n---\n\n## 6) 审计意见（针对“多 subagent 调度实践”）\n\n**结论：通过（附条件）**\n\n通过理由：\n- 当前宪章已具备完整状态机、权限边界、升级规则与双签铁律；\n- 角色分工清晰，可支持多 subagent 并行协作；\n- 已定义失败入刑部机制，具备可恢复性。\n\n附条件（不满足则自动转“驳回”）：\n1. 调度前必须声明预算阈值与并发上限；\n2. 工部动作前必须拿到门下+兵部双签；\n3. 命中升级条件时不得继续推进，先上报谷老板；\n4. 全流程保留可追踪证据与归档记录。\n"},"partialJson":"{\"path\":\"/Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace/org/AUDIT_CHECKLIST.md\",\"content\":\"# 执行前审计清单（门下省）\\n\\n- 审计对象：`org/CONSTITUTION_v1.md` + 即将执行的多 subagent 调度实践\\n- 审计时间：2026-03-08\\n- 审计结论：**通过（附硬性前置条件）**\\n\\n---\\n\\n## 1) 安全红线（任一命中即停止执行）\\n\\n1. **未完成双签即进入工部执行**（门下 + 兵部）\\n2. **越权决策**：Val 或任何 subagent 代替谷老板拍板重大/不明确事项\\n3. **对外发送/公开发布**未先触发上报与授权\\n4. **不可逆操作**（删除/覆盖/资金动作）未获明确批准\\n5. **隐私外发或安全边界变更**（权限、网络暴露、密钥流转）未经上报\\n6. **规避审计链路**：跳过 Audit/Verify/Archive 或缺失可追踪日志\\n7. **失败后绕过刑部**直接重试/继续推进\\n\\n---\\n\\n## 2) 成本红线（任一命中即触发降级或暂停）\\n\\n1. **单任务预算未声明**（Token/时间）即开始调度\\n2. **实际消耗超过预算上限**且未触发户部预警与降本动作\\n3. **并发 subagent 数超出控制阈值**，导致上下文重复/空转调用\\n4. **重复审计或重复执行**（同一产出无增量循环）\\n5. **高成本工具调用无必要性说明**（浏览器/长链路执行等）\\n6. **无里程碑止损点**，出现长时间任务漂移\\n\\n> 建议默认控制：\\n> - 每轮仅保留必要并发（先小并发验证，再扩容）\\n> - 每阶段设“预算闸门 + 继续条件”\\n\\n---\\n\\n## 3) 升级条件（满足任一必须上报谷老板）\\n\\n依据宪章第4条并细化如下：\\n\\n1. 涉及对外发送或公开发布\\n2. 涉及不可逆操作\\n3. 涉及隐私外发或安全边界变化\\n4. 单任务预算/Token 预估超阈值或已超阈值\\n5. 审计结论高不确定性（证据不足、前提冲突、结果不可复现）\\n6. 跨角色冲突无法在一轮内收敛（如门下与尚书结论冲突）\\n7. 连续失败进入刑部后仍无法给出低风险修复路径\\n\\n---\\n\\n## 4) 否决条件（门下省可直接驳回）\\n\\n1. 任务目标不清且验收标准缺失，无法形成可审计任务单\\n2. 明确违反“用户目标优先/安全可控优先”最高原则\\n3. 缺少关键前置信息但仍要求直接执行\\n4. 试图绕开双签铁律或失败处理铁律\\n5. 成本明显失衡（收益不匹配风险与资源投入）\\n6. 需要谷老板拍板但请求方拒绝上报\\n\\n---\\n\\n## 5) 执行前 Gate（放行前必须逐项打勾）\\n\\n- [ ] 已完成任务单（目标/范围/步骤/工具/风险/验收/预算）\\n- [ ] 门下审计结论明确（通过/补充后放行/驳回）\\n- [ ] 兵部安全确认完成\\n- [ ] 升级条件检查完成（如命中已上报）\\n- [ ] 尚书分发含里程碑、责任人、止损点\\n- [ ] 失败回路已定义（刑部介入条件 + 回滚策略）\\n- [ ] 汇报模板字段齐全（结论/证据/风险/选项+推荐）\\n\\n---\\n\\n## 6) 审计意见（针对“多 subagent 调度实践”）\\n\\n**结论：通过（附条件）**\\n\\n通过理由：\\n- 当前宪章已具备完整状态机、权限边界、升级规则与双签铁律；\\n- 角色分工清晰，可支持多 subagent 并行协作；\\n- 已定义失败入刑部机制，具备可恢复性。\\n\\n附条件（不满足则自动转“驳回”）：\\n1. 调度前必须声明预算阈值与并发上限；\\n2. 工部动作前必须拿到门下+兵部双签；\\n3. 命中升级条件时不得继续推进，先上报谷老板；\\n4. 全流程保留可追踪证据与归档记录。\\n\"}"}],"api":"openai-responses","provider":"sub2api","model":"gpt-5.3-codex","usage":{"input":6351,"output":1286,"cacheRead":4608,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":12245,"cost":{"input":0,"output":0,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1772942511758}}
{"type":"message","id":"1c4fa7ee","parentId":"3cfd886b","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:02:16.196Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_C7V4RvF3EDo1E6uConsg9sdo|fc_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4b34c108191a028a4e842327164","toolName":"write","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Successfully wrote 1489 bytes to /Users/guchen/.openclaw/workspace/org/AUDIT_CHECKLIST.md"}],"isError":false,"timestamp":1772942536194}}
{"type":"message","id":"0bf7bf49","parentId":"1c4fa7ee","timestamp":"2026-03-08T04:02:21.228Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"**Adding pass/reject with reason and path**","thinkingSignature":"{\"id\":\"rs_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4c96ea48191879d2d23d70cffab\",\"type\":\"reasoning\",\"encrypted_content\":\"gAAAAABprPTKt2yf2zHmlw72WZvmBTFsskYPkJukla0xQF7poE1DxzNMFwBTM6sPP2U3Zv7G97kb2R1vIkXx5Fkovr5WEeObd5MORC1vDLYwWlhCSKMUnsQk_0oS56u970LpgHDxsm1UZwNHYuLMCLmCAANy_F5irKbThWjmR3d1Mng7J4ai_Zm0puR0SRAbO80OBwuDFUru1iFp83ptuBJR91xlJxW9JrvClGrrGhdTyRuiauyYnO3vBzjeshWO6O5FxL8phTjVfsXKUMwEtQ7qOACnP8vQh8PYLxQ79fnFIT0GliFcfy1afRB9vGBc3QrQ62xZngraV2XKMoNwjObikybEUZd8HqnAoein4xLrPqk7Dx8L4EnVGRkTfP7LdVWUeQnE9xv9nVok8HntY-G6ugLcUIx3foKI6Jn0zFK30yY3152eBW_p7T2wvvOuRm9a5zimFEUv9uV7GT-GjZBGu4v3kWiIBc00oJgPuU_ZrCI7JA3m-7xUujyREJU97YlJ3UUUKlpbkle9erQB9JW1BGRQf4gOoTeZGcyaXmxJ4UKZV0S-6zWKLoG8A9QZbtysoKoEVcfXqkSH_N4vH-N2tjqFmhwiB_F5OZQQSsvd3ZgQ07KbW3pJWHA0E1sa0rucB5EqzTquZdiVJ9-8aht2I9kVnyo2nd16_-ZGEXfIoUHw0-0q_KTPTNkaXcOO64dOsd9sSla-UObVLTvDXl-EofDJcagyMqzdrsis4tY99zXDUlwCesQ7SvbgDAainOElt80cjlsjdwsKjorCQYQCyZXbQB-PdcljhK83PlFuUtphiV9sSmG7MboQ9Gz9HENyzf2fbZaTDQF36LHVcqnkqv76YdW4rxhCIUsAzKQmEc-Tq8WhqNpeXnpn8to6RxvWLaOUx7cyoZoYuePz5T0vnh63n6Ayvg==\",\"summary\":[{\"type\":\"summary_text\",\"text\":\"**Adding pass/reject with reason and path**\"}]}"},{"type":"text","text":"已完成审计并生成文件：\n\n- 输出文件：`org/AUDIT_CHECKLIST.md`\n- 结论：**通过（附硬性前置条件）**\n\n**通过理由（简要）**\n1. 宪章已具备完整流程状态机（Intake→Archive）与可追踪机制。  \n2. 权限边界明确（Val 与谷老板决策权分层清晰）。  \n3. 双签铁律（门下+兵部）与失败入刑部机制可控。  \n\n**附条件（任一不满足即转驳回）**\n- 调度前声明预算阈值与并发上限；\n- 工部执行前完成门下+兵部双签；\n- 命中升级条件必须先上报谷老板；\n- 全流程留存证据日志与归档记录。","textSignature":"msg_0ae9682a7ba351280169acf4ca429c8191b5ef43777312490d"}],"api":"openai-responses","provider":"sub2api","model":"gpt-5.3-codex","usage":{"input":1527,"output":207,"cacheRead":10752,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":12486,"cost":{"input":0,"output":0,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0}},"stopReason":"stop","timestamp":1772942536197}}